IFS, EMDR and Talk Therapy: What Is the Difference?

By Elizabeth Meyer, LCSW. Licensed in Oregon (L18011) and California (LIC #22048).

Talk therapy works through conversation and insight. Internal Family Systems (IFS) treats the mind as made of "parts" and helps you relate to them with curiosity and compassion. EMDR uses a structured protocol with bilateral stimulation, such as guided eye movements, to help the brain reprocess distressing memories. They are not rivals. The right one depends on what you are working on and what feels workable for you.

Talk therapy

Most people picture this one. We talk, notice patterns, and build understanding of what keeps you stuck. It suits a wide range of concerns and is a good fit when you want to explore, make sense of experience, or work through a decision. My talk therapy is collaborative: we work out the patterns together, and the direction is yours to set.

Internal Family Systems (IFS)

IFS was developed by Dr. Richard Schwartz. It starts from the idea that everyone has many inner parts, each with its own perspective and good intentions, even the parts that cause pain. At the center is the Self, a calm and compassionate core. In sessions we slow down and turn attention inward, getting curious about the parts that show up with anxiety, self-doubt, anger or sadness. People often find it helpful for self-criticism, shame, feeling stuck or conflicted, and relationship patterns.

EMDR

EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) was developed by Dr. Francine Shapiro and follows an eight-phase protocol. It is recognized by the World Health Organization, the American Psychiatric Association and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs as an effective treatment for trauma and PTSD. Unlike talk therapy, you do not have to describe your experience in detail, and there is no homework between sessions. It also works over video: the bilateral stimulation can be done on screen once we set it up together.

How to choose

If you are looking forOne place to start
Space to talk, reflect and understand patternsTalk therapy
A way to understand and soften inner conflict, self-criticism or shameIFS
Relief from specific distressing memories or trauma symptomsEMDR

This is a starting point, not a rule. Many people use more than one, and I blend them with mindfulness, Polyvagal exercises and attention to the body. In our first conversations we figure out what fits, and we adjust as we go. I will tell you if something is not working.

Ready to Begin?

Taking the first step toward healing is an act of courage. Reach out today. I'd love to connect.

Contact Elizabeth

Currently accepting new clients · Daytime and evening appointments